Valuation and Refinancing of the Marital Residence

by | Apr 13, 2018 | Blog | 49 comments

Over the years, I have seen several approaches used by divorcing couples to value the marital residence for their settlement. Listed in order of precision and reliability:

  • Arbitrary agreement
  • Zillow/Trulia estimates
  • County tax assessor’s value
  • Realtor Comparative Market Analysis (CMA)
  • Appraisal obtained from a licensed appraiser

The purpose of this article is not to assess the strengths and weaknesses of the above methodologies. Rather, if the ultimate outcome of the divorce is for one spouse to retain and refinance the marital residence (“grantee spouse”), then it is highly recommended to start the refinance process concurrently with the divorce timeline and use the lender’s appraisal in finalizing the settlement terms.

 

Five Important Reasons to Start the Mortgage Refinance While the Divorce is in Process

  1. To determine, up front, if the grantee spouse can actually obtain the new mortgage. So many times, I see the “must refinance” requirement in the decree without ANY pre-qualification whatsoever. If the spouse cannot qualify, wouldn’t it make sense to know, so the parties are not just going through the motions and end up having to sell the home six or twelve months later? If the spouse does not qualify now, but could, given a game plan and time (e.g., building employment history for a stay-at-home mom or repairing credit), the settlement could be drafted with an appropriate performance deadline.
  1. To avoid valuation issues (low appraisals) later, which could render the refinance undoable. No matter what method is used for the settlement, if there is a         subsequent refinance to be done, the only valuation method that is acceptable to the lender/investor is the appraisal ordered by the mortgage company. PERIOD. Here is a real-life example of a client who came to me after the divorce was final:

Grantee spouse obtained an appraisal for $260,000. Grantor spouse, not believing the valuation and wanting to maximize the value to receive more proceeds, obtained another appraisal for $300,000. They agreed to meet in the middle, at $280,000. The payoff on the mortgage was $200,000. The plan was to do a cash-out refinance at $224,000 (80% of the agreed upon “value”), rolling in $4,000 of closing costs to the new loan and paying a “buy-out” to the grantor spouse of $20,000. All the numbers worked great. Except when our mortgage appraisal came back at $265,000. As you can see in the table below, the available proceeds came up $12,000 short, based on the mortgage appraisal.

Divorce Decree Mortgage Refinance
Marital Residence Value $280,000 $265,000
New Refinance Loan (80%) $224,000 $212,000
Less Payoff ($200,000) ($200,000)
Less Closing Costs (rolled in) ($4,000) ($4,000)
Available to Pay Grantor Spouse $20,000 $8,000

This scenario created much difficulty for the grantee spouse. He didn’t have the liquid assets to come up with the shortage. And who wants to go back to court to modify? In this case, an Owelty refinance would probably have been a better solution. Had the appraisal been completed before the divorce was final, it would have been a simple change to make.

  1. To shorten the waiting time for the grantor spouse to receive his/her funds from the refinance. Using a concurrent timeline with the divorce process, we typically have refinance proceeds to the grantor spouse within one to two weeks after the prove up.
  1. To make sure the refinance language in the divorce decree is appropriate for the client’s circumstances. For example, should it be an Owelty or a cash-out refinance? Numerous factors can affect which type of refinance is best for the client’s situation, such as credit score, equity in the home, has the home equity been borrowed against previously, has the house been listed for sale in the last six months, etc.
  1. To lower the odds of self-sabotage by either party, whether intentional or not. I will never forget the procrastinating client who was referred to me by her attorney SEVERAL months earlier. When she finally reached out to me, everything looked perfect, until I pulled her credit report. Unbeknownst to her, a recent missed payment by her ex (on the joint auto loan he was assigned in the decree) tanked her credit scores, and she was not able to refinance. Had she initiated the process earlier, this would have been avoided.

 

How Does the Mortgage Appraisal Timing Work?

Typically, a mortgage appraisal is good for 120 days. If market values are deteriorating, as was the case during the real estate meltdown of 2008-2012, you may see some lenders requiring updating and recertification after 90 days.

It is important to assess how long the divorce process is going to take. Will it be 60 days or six months? We don’t want to order the appraisal too soon in the process, but we definitely want our attorney/client to have the information as soon as appropriate if it is needed for mediation and/or to finalize the settlement figures. I have found that if I order the appraisal 30-45 days before the anticipated prove up, that is enough time to have the information available to the parties, as well as give us some reasonable float time in case the process takes longer than expected.

 

One More Thing: Pay Attention to THIS in Case of “Dueling” Appraisals

There are several different report formats used by appraisers. They all have different scopes and intended uses. The main concern of most attorneys when they order an appraisal is the final value and how it will affect their case. However, if you find yourself in the position of going to court over competing appraisals, the actual appraisal form may have an impact on the outcome of your hearing.

By far, the most common form used is the Uniform Residential Appraisal Report (URAR) 1004 form. This is the “go to” form used by appraisers and, unless

otherwise specified, will likely be the report you receive. Technically, however, this report format is not valid for court purposes. If you read the fine print, you will note that the intended use of a URAR 1004 is “for the lender/client to evaluate the property that is the subject of the appraisal for a mortgage finance transaction.”

So, in the future (if you are not already doing so), make sure you order a General Purpose Appraisal Report (GPAR) if you are going to court. And, if opposing counsel submits a URAR, you may have grounds to argue the admissibility of their report because its intended use is not acceptable.

49 Comments

  10. n1betapp on June 15, 2026 at 9:40 am

    I’ve tried a few platforms before but this one is just smoother. The mobile experience is top-notch and everything loads instantly. Highly recommend checking out n1betapp if you want a hassle-free experience.

  11. k9winlogin on June 15, 2026 at 9:41 am

    Finally found a site that doesn’t lag during peak hours. The interface is clean and the login process is super quick. Love using k9winlogin for my daily sessions.

  12. istana777login on June 15, 2026 at 9:41 am

    The payouts here are actually fair and the customer support is very helpful. It feels like a premium community. Definitely give istana777login a try.

  15. Dante2443 on June 18, 2026 at 2:40 pm

    Новинки музыки 2026 скачать бесплатно https://shorturl.fm/pj0rJ

  38. ph80jilicasino on July 17, 2026 at 6:13 am

    Jili games are my favorite and this platform hosts them perfectly. The gameplay is seamless and the rewards are generous. You should definitely give ph80jilicasino a try.

  39. betonwincasinochile on July 17, 2026 at 6:13 am

    Best betting experience I have had in Chile so far. The customer support is actually helpful and responds quickly to my questions. Big thumbs up for betonwincasinochile.

  40. mywin4u on July 17, 2026 at 6:14 am

    Finally found a site that actually treats its players well. The bonuses are fair and the support team is very helpful. Visit mywin4u

  43. phoneclubcasino on October 8, 2026 at 3:20 am

    Alright, phoneclubcasino, you’ve got my attention! Seems like a decent spot to try my luck. Fingers crossed! Check it out here: phoneclubcasino

  44. auvictor96 on October 10, 2026 at 5:45 pm

    I recently started exploring newer casino sites and this one completely exceeded my expectations. The mobile interface is perfectly optimized and I can play comfortably on the go without any clunky menus. Customer support responds within minutes and they always solve my questions on the first chat. I really respect how they handle fairness and keep their licensing info right at the top of the homepage. It is exactly the kind of trustworthy spot I have been searching for all year. Good luck to everyone spinning tonight. auvictor96

  45. bdbet365login on October 13, 2026 at 12:31 pm

    Just found this platform and I am already completely hooked on the experience. Registration took less than two minutes and I was ready to play right away. Withdrawals hit my account faster than I expected and the odds are genuinely competitive. bdbet365login

  46. pj777app on October 18, 2026 at 9:10 pm

    I switched from another site and the difference is night and day. The bonus terms are actually reasonable and I can cash out my winnings in record time. Everything runs perfectly on my phone and the customer team is always just a message away. Start your winning streak today pj777app

  47. krwinna on October 19, 2026 at 12:36 pm

    The winning streaks I’ve had here are insane. It feels like the RNG is actually fair for once. Cheers to krwinna for the awesome vibes.

  48. pkdaulat7game on October 20, 2026 at 2:53 pm

    The game variety here is just amazing. I spent hours exploring different options and the payouts are fair. Definitely check out pkdaulat7game if you want some real excitement.

  49. tk444app on October 21, 2026 at 10:36 am

    Alright, so I gave tk444app a shot. Honestly, not bad! Signed up was super easy, and they’ve got a decent selection to keep you busy. I’m not saying it’s perfect, but it’s worth checking out if you’re looking for something new. Check it out here: tk444app.

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *